ETFcomparison.org
vs.
by klos ✦

VOO Our Pick vs. VTI

Vanguard S&P 500 ETF vs. Vanguard Total Stock Market Index Fund ETF Shares

Correlation
100%
VOO CAGR
+13.63%
VTI CAGR
+13.06%

Buy VOO if…

  • You prioritize historical performance

Buy VTI if…

  • you like the idea of owning "everything"

Vanguard Classics

VOO and VTI are both Vanguard index ETFs, but they track different slices of the market. VOO follows the S&P 500, so you're getting the 500 largest US companies — think Apple, Microsoft, Nvidia, the usual suspects. VTI goes wider and tracks the total US stock market, which means you get those same big names plus mid-caps and small-caps, around 3,600+ stocks total. In practice though, both are heavily weighted toward constantly growing their share large-caps, so their performance is pretty similar.

It becomes a bit of a philosophical question: how much diversification is enough?

Most people settle on the "500 stocks" answer, but honestly, you can't go wrong with either option.

Jan Klosowski
Read my blog →
Dollar-cost averaging (DCA) often provides a more realistic estimate of actual investment performance, as it reflects how most investors gradually invest over time. This simulation assumes monthly purchases.
Type
ETF
ETF
Exchange
NYSE ARCA
NYSE ARCA
Currency
USD
USD
Issuer
Vanguard
Vanguard
Holdings
503
3,336
Index
S&P 500
CRSP US Total Market
AUM
$825B
$569B
Inception
2010
2001

Key Metrics

Expense Ratio
0.03%
0.03%
Dividend Yield
+1.15%
+1.14%
Daily Liquidity
7.40M
3.81M
Risk (β)
1.00
1.04

Expense Ratio Calculator

$
%
VOO Fees
$0
VTI Fees
$0

Annualized Returns

YTD
+18.42%
+17.79%
1 Year
+14.48%
+13.33%
3 Years
+21.46%
+20.79%
5 Years
+14.88%
+13.66%
10 Years
+14.66%
+14.12%

Top 10 Holdings

NVIDIA Corporation
8.46%
NVIDIA Corporation
7.13%
Apple Inc
6.87%
Apple Inc
6.12%
Microsoft Corporation
6.59%
Microsoft Corporation
5.87%
Amazon.com Inc
4.06%
Amazon.com Inc
3.58%
Broadcom Inc
2.98%
Broadcom Inc
2.65%
Alphabet Inc Class A
2.80%
Alphabet Inc Class A
2.50%
Meta Platforms Inc.
2.41%
Meta Platforms Inc.
2.15%
Alphabet Inc Class C
2.25%
Alphabet Inc Class C
1.99%
Tesla Inc
2.19%
Tesla Inc
1.91%
Berkshire Hathaway Inc
1.50%
Berkshire Hathaway Inc
1.31%

Related Comparisons

Compare VOO to:

Compare VTI to:

Sector Breakdown

VOO VTI